Senate Democrats are split over whether to risk another government shutdown to force an end to the Iran war, with federal funding set to expire on December 11. Four senators demand any short-term funding deal bar the Trump administration from using appropriated money to continue the war. Others warn a shutdown two weeks before Christmas would be a disaster.

The demand came in a letter last week from Chris Van Hollen of Maryland, Michael Bennet of Colorado, Bernie Sanders of Vermont and Tammy Duckworth of Illinois: "We should not accept a short-term spending deal that continues to provide billions of additional dollars for President Trump's war of choice. Any short-term package must include language that restricts the Trump Administration from using appropriated funds to continue his war against Iran."

“Under our current leadership, we have a situation where they are not willing to use the most important power we have to end the war, which is to defund it.”— Chris Van Hollen, U.S. Senator (D-Md.)

The Details

The pushback has been blunt. Vermont Senator Peter Welch said a shutdown would cause "a lot of hardship on people" and that he is "skeptical a shutdown would help pursue that goal." Nevada Senator Catherine Cortez Masto also opposes forcing a shutdown. "Nobody I've talked to thinks a shutdown makes any sense," said Jeanne Shaheen of New Hampshire. John Hickenlooper of Colorado warned that "a shutdown of government right before the holidays is a tough nut."

The fight is also about who leads the party. Chuck Schumer, who has led Senate Democrats for a decade, has repeatedly said the Iran war must end and a shutdown must be avoided — without saying whether the caucus would withhold its funding votes. His challenger for majority leader, Chris Van Hollen, has indicated a shutdown would be worth the pain. "Under our current leadership, we have a situation where they are not willing to use the most important power we have to end the war, which is to defund it," Van Hollen said in Denver last week. The leadership election is December 1. Schumer has said Congress should use its "power of the purse" to end the war.

Republicans warn the Democrats' stance will trigger a third shutdown in just over a year. "As of right now, the Democrats aren't engaging in a conversation at all when it comes to funding the government," Senate Majority Leader John Thune told reporters. "That's a problem, which again suggests perhaps they are thinking about yet a third government shutdown, which would be a really, really bad outcome for the country." Senate Republicans are fast-tracking a party-line budget bill that could send the Pentagon hundreds of billions of new dollars.

How We Got Here

The war is eight and a half months old and unpopular across the political spectrum, and the spike in gas prices that followed it helped drive Democratic turnout in the midterms, when the party swept to commanding majorities. Both chambers already voted symbolically to end the war this year, and the House has passed multiple resolutions to cease hostilities. "The president's ignored it," said Tim Kaine of Virginia. Withholding funding, in his view, has become "the only lever (Democrats) have."

Democrats have already been part of two record-breaking shutdowns in the 119th Congress, each lasting weeks, with hundreds of thousands of government employees going without pay. Last Friday, an air traffic control malfunction canceled and delayed flights nationwide — a preview of the travel chaos a shutdown brings, as TSA agents and controllers work without pay.

Reactions

Senate Democrats emerged from their weekly lunch on Tuesday saying they had "productive" discussions about the war and funding. Jack Reed, the top Democrat on the Senate Armed Services Committee, summed up the bind: "There's an appreciation that it's really essential that we do not shut the government down. But at the same time, we have to find a way to channel the feeling of the American public."

Why It Matters

Because of the Senate's 60-vote threshold, at least some Democrats would need to vote with Republicans to avert a funding lapse. The fight is also a preview of how Democrats will use their new majorities in the final two years of the Trump administration.

What Happens Next

The caucus must decide before December 11 whether to attach the Iran restriction to the stopgap bill. If it does and Republicans refuse, the country faces a third shutdown in just over a year. If it does not, the war funding continues. The leadership vote on December 1 will settle who makes that call.